Announcement 08/04/2025
Ban List E15
Ban List E15 :
Channel
Chatterstorm
Disciple of the Vault
Experimental Synthesizer
Fall from Favor
Glacial Chasm
Kraark-Clan Shaman
Merchant Scroll
Mystic Sanctuary
Deban : Mana Drain, Berserk
Hear ye, hear ye!
After a long wait, the Peasant Committee is back with an announcement packed with exciting updates. We're bringing news of a change in the Committee's lineup, a clarification of certain rules, a shift in how we communicate, some adjustments to the banlist, and a quick overview of the current meta.
Composition of the Committee
As many of you already know, Zebigcoconut has left the Committee. After many years of service to the community, he wanted to address you one last time officially to the community:
"Dear fellow peasants,
I have spent the last eight years testing, playing, and discussing with many of you. It has been a real pleasure and an opportunity for meaningful encounters and great moments of camaraderie. However, for several months now, I have not been as interested in Peasant, and I do not wish to invest myself in it moving forward. Therefore, I am announcing my departure from the Committee, as I no longer feel legitimate in holding this position. I would like to acknowledge the work of the other Committee members, in whom I have full confidence to ensure the continuity of the work already done. It has been an honor to be part of this adventure with all of you. I look forward to seeing you again, whether it’s at a tournament or during a conversation on Discord.
Your devoted servant,
Maxime aka Zebigcoconut"
It is with gratitude and respect that we extend a heartfelt thank you to Zebigcoconut for his dedication to the Peasant Committee. His work and commitment have been invaluable to the community, helping to develop and refine our format with both rigor and passion.
Although his time on the Committee is coming to an end, his involvement in the Peasant format is far from over. He remains a key figure, especially as the organizer of the largest annual tournament in Chalon-sur-Saône — a must-attend event for all enthusiasts.
Thank you again, Zebigcoconut, for everything you’ve brought to our community and all that you’ll continue to bring. See you soon around a game table!
To help fill the gap left by his departure, Phalangel has joined us. Here’s a message from him as he steps into this new role:
Hello Peasant community!
I think I know the vast majority of you, but if not, here’s a quick intro: my name is Maxime (yes, apparently that’s a requirement for joining the Committee!), I’m 32 years old, I’ve been playing Magic for quite a while, and I’ve been into Peasant since August 2022.
Why did I want to join the Committee?
I really enjoy the format, but above all, I don’t want to see it fade away. I find it interesting and generally diverse, even if there are occasional lulls. And most of all, I appreciate the community around it.
With Zebig stepping down, I felt it was a shame not to have anyone representing the Chalon community anymore. I also believe having more members is a good thing — more voices, more perspectives on the game, which helps deepen discussions, especially when it comes to bans/unbans, the format evolving with more and more set releases, power creep, and the different kinds of experiences players are looking for.
To wrap up, a few words about how I see the format:
To me, Peasant is both a “competitive” and “casual” format. That means in low-stakes tournaments, there’s absolutely nothing wrong — as long as both players agree — with playing chill, letting someone take back a move (within reason, of course).
On the flip side, in bigger events with serious prizes on the line, I think it’s totally fair for both players to go all-in and pay close attention to their decisions — that’s what makes the game truly exciting.
With that mindset, I think it’s cool to allow players to do certain “broken” things — like Ghostly Flicker loops in Ux Tron, infinite tokens with KCI, or making your opponent discard two cards for the price of one with Hymn to Tourach. As long as it doesn’t hurt the health of the format, like Kuldotha did back in early 2023, it keeps things spicy.
Sorry if that was a bit long! Looking forward to chatting and/or battling on Cockatrice… or even better, in person!
Maxime aka Phalangel
We’re thrilled to welcome Phalangel to the team. No need to worry, dear Peasant friends — you won’t feel too out of place. We’ve simply swapped one Maxime from the Chalon community… for another Maxime from the Chalon community!
Deckbuilding Rules Clarification for the Format
Basic Land Rarity Acknowledgement
Wizards of the Coast introduced a new rarity a few years ago on Gatherer: Basic Land rarity. This rarity doesn’t only appear on actual basic lands, but also on various other lands that are included in booster packs in the basic land slot.
Some cards have only been printed with this rarity — for example, lands from Outlaws of Thunder Junction such as Creosote Heath and others. This rarity is indicated by an “L” next to the collector number, where you would normally find a “C” for common or a “U” for uncommon.
These cards are considered commons in various formats, but this rarity had not yet been officially acknowledged in Peasant rules.
We believe it is important to clarify that these cards are legal in Peasant and may be played as if they had common rarity, up to four copies per deck.
Minimum Number of Commons
The rules were previously unclear regarding how to handle uncommons that allow players to exceed the usual limit of 5 uncos (e.g. Nazgûl or Templar Knight), due to a note stating that a deck must include at least 55 commons. This unnecessary detail has caused confusion, so we’ve decided to remove it.
Implementation of the changes
This leads to the following change in the format’s deckbuilding rules:
The current wording...
Construction rules
A Peasant deck follows the usual rules for building a deck (60 cards minimum with a maximum of 4 copies of any one card) and must contain:
at least 55 common cards
maximum 5 Uncommons (sideboard included)
no rare or mythique
The rarity of a card is defined as the lowest rarity among the rarities present on the Gatherer, provided that within this edition it is a card with which the player can start a game
In practice we always consider the lowest rarity in the gatherer.
Timeshifted cards are considered as rare.
Currently Nazgûl is the only card allowing to incorpore more than 5 uncos in a deck. (12/06/23)
Allowed Set
Every legal set in Type 1 are allowed (Commander set and Planechase included).
Promotionnal cards aren’t allowed
Virtual set are allowed (Each card from a virtual set exist in paper)
Renaissance and Anthologies set aren’t allowed because of a lack of informations about the rarities in these sets, (and these sets aren’t displayed on the Gatherer)
Unglued, Unhinged and Unstable aren’t allowed
...is replaced with the following :
Deckbuilding Rules
A Peasant deck (including sideboard) follows standard deck construction rules: a minimum of 60 cards with no more than four copies of any individual card. It may only contain cards with the rarities Common, Basic Land, or Uncommon. Cards in the deck (sideboard included) with the Uncommon rarity are limited to five.
A card’s rarity is determined according to its rarity listed on Gatherer.
2.1. A card is considered Common or Basic Land if it has at least one printing with that rarity on Gatherer.
2.2. A card is considered Uncommon if it has no printing as a Common or Basic Land on Gatherer, and has at least one printing as an Uncommon.
A deck may contain more than five Uncommon cards only if it includes cards that explicitly allow more than five copies of themselves to be included in a deck (e.g., Nazgûl, Templar Knight). In this case, all Uncommon cards in the deck must have the same card name as listed on Gatherer.
Only cards legal in Vintage (formerly Type 1) are allowed, provided they meet the above rarity conditions.
Clarifications (based on the rules above):
Rarity Clarifications:
A card cannot be included in a deck if it does not have a printing at Common, Basic Land, or Uncommon rarity as defined above (e.g., a card only ever printed as Rare on Gatherer is not legal).
The Renaissance and Anthologies sets are not used to determine a card’s rarity (these sets are not listed on Gatherer).
The rarity of cards from the Conjure mechanic is not considered when establishing rarity (as these cards do not appear on Gatherer).
Digital-only editions are taken into account when determining rarity, as long as they are listed on Gatherer. Since there can be a delay before digital cards appear there, it may be useful to consult an external site like scryfall.com until the edition is listed on Gatherer.
Digital-only sets refer to those exclusive to Magic: The Gathering Online and Magic: The Gathering Arena.
Legal Card Clarifications:
Cards from Commander and Planechase sets are allowed (since they are Vintage-legal).
Cards from Unglued, Unhinged, and Unstable are not allowed (they are not Vintage-legal).
Cards that reference stickers, attractions, or have the acorn-shaped holofoil from the Unfinity set are not allowed (they are not Vintage-legal).
Communication
The Bureau
A new entity has entered the format: the Bureau. It is a group of players motivated to promote the format and expand the player base. Its actions are independent of the Committee. Of course, there are more or less direct links between these two distinct yet complementary entities, whose common goal is to work for the well-being and longevity of Peasant.
We are very pleased that the community is innovating to promote the format, and we hope that you have all already subscribed to the various social media platforms that the Bureau is currently reactivating.
Calendrier des annonces du comité
We are committed to resuming more regular announcements from us after a year that has been more than scarce in communication. We have therefore decided to implement an announcement schedule for the coming years, which is not restrictive; we will reach out to you outside of these dates if necessary.
You can look forward to hearing from us at least every 3 months on the following dates:
A New Year's announcement between January 31st and February 15th, following the annual Master tournament.
A Spring announcement between April 30th and May 15th.
A Summer announcement between July 31st and August 15th, following the GroPez, which will allow us to take the temperature after the last regular event before the CDF and the summer set, which tends to strongly impact the format.
An announcement between October 31st and November 15th, following the CDF, to provide feedback on the most important tournament of the year and any adjustments that may result from it.
Unless in exceptional cases, we will not modify the banlist outside of these announcements. We want to note that we try to avoid making changes too close to major paper tournaments to maintain fairness among players,
Banlist
We are getting a bit ahead of our new schedule and are proposing the following changes, which will take effect from April 28, 2025:
The card Mana Drain has been removed from the banned list.
The card Berserk has been removed from the banned list.
Mana Drain
To begin, the question that some will ask is the consideration of price. Mana Drain is a card that is on the borderline of acceptable prices for a card in the format, but we always weigh the price against the card's representation in the format. Mana Drain does not seem to be a card that will be played as a 4-of in the decks that would want to use it. If the card ever became a must-play four-of in many decks of the format, we would revisit our decision for budgetary reasons. Accessibility of the format is and will always remain an important factor in the construction of the banned list.
Mana Drain seems to be a relevant upgrade for the blue color by bringing counterspells back into the spotlight, considering that the iconic Counterspell has lost some of its power over the years. The Uncommon status does not make Mana Drain a mandatory replacement for Counterspell, but it will allow Ux Control decks to gain tempo and keep up with the evolving threats of the format. We hope to rebalance the color pie with this removal from the banned list.
Berserk
Infect has long been an archetype that was difficult to keep under control in the metagame. It no longer seems necessary to limit its Uncommon options, now that decks generally have fast responses to the threats present in the format. The difference with Scale Up being limited, the impact of this decision on Infect will be equally limited.
Additionally, Berserk seems to be an interesting option that other, more aggro-oriented archetypes may want to test.
Meta overview
Watchlist
In our last announcement, we mentioned closely monitoring two cards:
Passageway Seer, which was being monitored due to the strong presence of the The Rock archetype.
Sicarian Infiltrator, which was being monitored due to the dominance of Ux Tron.
Following changes in the metagame, these two archetypes are on the decline, and these cards are not currently causing any particular issues. Additionally, recent developments in The Rock have shifted focus away from Passageway Seer in favor of The Aesir Escape Valhalla.
Commentary on the Metagame
Over the past six months, from the 2024 CDF to today, Kuldotha, Wee Bee, and Broodscale Combo seem to be leading the metagame, with 18, 17, and 17 performances, respectively. Elves and The Rock follow closely behind, each with 13 performances.
Among the dominant archetypes, we can note a few aggro decks (Kuldotha, Red Assault, and Elves), a majority of midrange decks (Wee Bee, The Rock, Affinity, and Madness), and several combo decks (Broodscale, Dredge, Wall, Storm, and Arcane Tide). Heavy control decks are struggling to break through, with only 4 UR lists, 4 Ux Tron, and 2 Smallpox/MonoB Control.
Nevertheless, during this period, around forty different archetypes have performed, totaling 155 performances, compared to about thirty with 134 performances at the same time last year. The results are more spread out: 9 decklists have more than 6 performances, compared to 6 last year. Last year, there was a strong dominance of Ux Tron among control decks, Kuldotha among aggro, and Arcane Tide among combo decks, but the latter was heavily controlled by Ux Tron and UB Faeries, which made it to the top due to their ability to manage Arcane Tide.
The metagame seems to be more open, with greater variety: each archetype is represented by several lists, except for the combo decks, which are still largely dominated by Broodscale.
Paper format
Peasant in paper format is making a comeback, and we are very happy to see the community relaunching tournaments in the form of qualifiers for the Coupe de France. Don’t hesitate to check out the nearby qualifiers and try organizing one yourself. The nxt one (at the end of April 2025) will be in Saint-Nazaire, and we hope to see many of you there.
The Dutch community is also becoming more active, and we hope this will inspire others to relaunch Peasant in countries where it was historically established.
Watch decks
Kuldotha
This deck is still considered the gatekeeper of the format:
"If you don’t do anything early, you die on turn 4, or even turn 3 with a good draw."
Wraths, now present in many sideboards and even main decks, are largely there to handle it. Still present despite the banning of Experimental Synthesizer last year, it remains less resilient in the late game. A Kuldotha Rebirth followed by a kicked Goblin Bushwhacker can be devastating, but once the board is stabilized, it struggles to recover. We keep an eye on it, but its role as the metronome for the format seems necessary.
Strengths: Fast aggression, ability to punish slow combo or control decks.
Weaknesses: Struggles against Wraths, recurring life gain combined with small creatures. Aesir, played in The Rock, is one of its worst enemies.
Wee Bee
Still dominant, it is nonetheless constrained by its mana base, although the inclusion of previously considered mediocre cards, like Fountainport Bell, has improved this aspect.
The deck shows good synergies:
Recursive discard
Recurring creature removal (Tithing Blade, Thraben Charm, Grim Bauble)
Flying creatures hard to deal with thanks to Omen of the Dead
However, it is often slowed down by Writhing Chrysalis, which, thanks to its reach, can block and kill Kor Skyfisher and other flying creatures.
Elves
The deck received a huge boost with the printing of Dionus. Thanks to Zomby33, it has won numerous 8-man tournaments and achieved some solid performances in pool play in recent months. But as meta decks have incorporated more Wraths, and players have adjusted their approach to the match-up, the deck has underperformed compared to its representation in the last Pool and in recent 8-mans. The deck is still strong, Dionus should be watched, but for now, it remains out of the ban hammer’s reach.
Broodscale Combo
A recent archetype, introduced with the printing of the card of the same name. It first performed in Pauper before making its way into Peasant during the 2024 CDF. The deck has improved with Ghost Lantern, played as a 5th or 6th Sadistic Glee, and Demonic Consultation, played as additional Sadistic Glee and Basking Broodscale.
It has many strengths:
The deck is based on a two-card combo that can be tutored for
It has discard and protection in the main deck
It has the ability to bring in Wraths from the sideboard and numerous copies of Last Rites
In general, it has room to adapt depending on the match-up.
It is more stable than High Tide or Storm, which require a lot of cards in hand to get going. Writhing Chrysalis has also joined the arsenal, providing a small aggro plan if the combo doesn’t go through. But the deck remains vulnerable—many answers are possible, although a single one is often not enough: targeted creature removal, enchantment removal, or counterspells. However, pressure (especially from Kuldotha) can be sufficient to force it to go off prematurely. It also shows weaknesses against less-represented decks: MonoB Control, UB Faeries, or faster aggro decks like Red Assault and Infect.
It remains under watch but does not seem to excessively dominate the metagame.
LSD
Finally, the LSD deck is also being watched: it wouldn’t take much for it to be able to consistently kill very early again. But its lack of performance, despite many attempts, suggests that other decks are still able to handle it, especially post-side, despite explosive starts (it can kill on turn 1 with a perfect hand).
Conclusion
The meta is evolving very quickly at the moment, and the limited number of players and paper tournaments makes it difficult to get a full picture.
Despite the lack of frequent official communication, the Committee is closely monitoring the meta's development and will not hesitate to take action should any issues arise.
The Peasant Committee